The worst mistake we writers can make is by Falling into the
trap. The writing trap. A large writing hole that we writers are prone to
falling into, due to several reasons; overuse of certain types of plot
lines, clichéd resolution, similar style of narrative in all the books we write,
even though the books may not be a part of a series, use of similar
settings, themes, use of similar protagonists in all the books, not deviating
from the same and often predictable thought patterns and plot twists.
This can be attributed to the fact that once a few writers
have discovered a successful formula, they want to milk it dry. Perhaps
they endorse the view why mess or meddle with something that has worked well.
But what they forget is that a certain style the readers may have adored once,
may not find takers again and again.
Many times I have felt a sense of Déjà vu when I read
the next set of books written by a few writers. I get the feeling
that I have met the characters before, at another time in another place. Even
the setting has no novelty as it’s the same one as the last book written
by the author. The problem faced by the main character and the way the
conflict has been resolved is something I had guessed halfway through the
book.
Today’s generation of readers have several things vying for
their limited and often straying attention. If the writer has nothing new
to offer they are quick to discard the book and the writer. The only way
we can avoid this vicious writing trap is by being original. This will
sustain the writer if he or she is in for the long haul. There are several
writers who have adopted this approach successfully: Roald Dahl; each book
of his was different from the other, for example there was no
similarity in any of these books; George’s Marvellous Medicine, Twits,
Mathilda, James and the Giant Peach, and Charlie and the Chocolate
factory.
Another writer who escaped this trap is J.K Rowling. Though
the seven potter books had the same setting of Hogwarts and the same set
of characters, each book had something new to offer. There were new
entrants who took us completely unawares, several times the plot took
unexpected twists that intrigued us. This trait of unpredictability keeps readers
interested.
Have you ever felt that a particular writer is
falling into the trap? How do you manage
to avoid the writing trap? Please share your views.
The element of predictability can kill the joy of reading and as you rightly said, cliche's are best avoided:)
ReplyDeleteTrue. But most of the authors I have read before have managed to keep things fresh. I vary the theme of my blog-posts frequently due to this very reason.
ReplyDeletewww.destinationinfinity.org
So true, Rachna. Every book needs to be fresh. And those are the sequels I enjoy.
ReplyDeleteI'm avoiding the trap by stopping at three books.
ReplyDeleteI think success with one kind of book can make it very tempting to keep churning them out, especially if they keep selling. Bit of a soul destroyer though.
ReplyDeletemood
Moody Writing
I've definitely read a few authors who I got tired of because it became clear that they had nothing new to offer. It seems sometimes, and maybe i'm just jaded, that the more commercially successful a writer is, the more likely they are to fall into the trap. The ones with starkly different stories tend to have fewer books and it seems clear that it's quality over quantity.
ReplyDeleteI agree. Even though some authors seem to stay with a 'formula', they lose their audience if they don't bring something new to each book. As authors our imagination is our life blood.
ReplyDeleteWriter after writer fell into the trap. Just hoping my characters are different enough from each other!
ReplyDeleteYou should definitely treat each story as an entity in its own right, even if it's part of a series. If a writer becomes formulaic, then it's like the characters are cardbaord cutouts made to fit a certain kind of plot. Some of the best characters are unpredictable even to the writer.
ReplyDeleteI have read a few writers that do what you say, they repeat themselves again and again. It does loss appeal with time. I've written quite a few stories myself, but I always tried to come up with something different. I'm easily bored by the same soup, even if I make it.
ReplyDeleteI focused on a different character in each of my five fiction books. Different personalities, different ages and problems - it gave it some variety.
ReplyDeleteThough it seems like it can be easy to revisit the same plot schemes, I'm hopeful that many of us like the idea of doing something new and fresh. I've seen it with a big author I liked when I was younger, and stopped reading his work when I noticed a whole chapter was from an earlier book. That's extreme! There're too many ideas and things to write about to recycle the same ones. Writer’s Mark
ReplyDeleteWhat an excellent post! I have definitely read books where I felt the author was following a similar formula. Sometimes when I love a book I want to read everything I can be the author and sometimes after reading a number of their books the plot seems worn out.
ReplyDeleteI love when authors can keep it fresh! You brought up great examples.
~Jess
Yes I too have read books that seem to follow a formula. It is good to give each book a fresh feel even if they are part of a series.
ReplyDeleteI'm in the middle of outlining another story and I've had to actively change a couple of characters and a theme which I'd used before. Oopsies!
ReplyDeleteThe worst thing a writer or an actor can do is be a prisoner of his own image.
ReplyDeleteThere are no easy answers to avoid the trap. Writer Arnab Ray wrote his first novel which was witty and widely acclaimed. His second novel was a horror/thriller which was rejected by his fans.Sometimes it doesn't work but one has to take risks.
Very interesting point, Rachna...
ReplyDeleteI dry to keep things fresh by writing in different genres and style... Only my atmospheric descriptions are prevalent in all of my stories...
Once my trilogy is complete, I will finish a couple stand alone novels with new characters. Then I'll loop back with another Chase Manhattan adventure.
ReplyDeleteI think this is a good way to keep from falling into this type of trap.
The way I see it, we all fall into traps...that's what rewriting is for:) Also, I mentioned you on my blog Rachna:)
ReplyDeleteI avoid the trap by not writing enough. I might be prone to falling in writing traps if I was writing a lot.
ReplyDeleteLee
Wrote By Rote
I'm all for originality.
ReplyDeleteI do get that deja vu feeling many times.